The proposed IRDAI amendments may result in significant modifications in the approach of life insurers to cost management and distribution of commission payments. These changes will include stricter restrictions on expense ratios and reinstating commission caps through various distribution channels. The impact of such changes will vary from insurer to insurer, depending on its portfolio of products and channel strategy. Investors need to pay attention to this issue.
Brokerage View
Systematix feels that the changes suggested by the IRDA will not be very positive for the majority of the private life insurance companies because the expenses and commission structure will have to be tightened. SBI Life would be less impacted than the rest because it has come very close to the suggested limit on expenses.
Proposed Expense Caps Could Increase Cost Pressure
IRDAI has proposed replacing the existing product-wise expense structure with a company-level expense cap for life insurers. Under the proposed framework, total expenses would be measured as a percentage of total premium. Insurers would have to bring this ratio down to 15% within two years and 12.5% within five years, starting FY28. Insurers already below the benchmark would have to move towards a 10% level.
Private Insurers Could Face a Significant Reduction
Such amendments might prove critical considering that the expense ratio of the private life insurance companies stood at about 20% for FY26. The Systematix analysis suggests that the implementation of such regulations will lead to 500–750 basis points of pressure compared to the present situation. Thus, the insurers will have to look for means of lowering their costs.
Commission Rules Are Also Being Tightened
Commission restrictions will be re-established as well. The definition of commission will be expanded to include not only rewards but also bonuses, gifts, travel expenses, reimbursements, and other similar amounts. The distributors functioning in open architectures like brokers and multi-tie banks will receive smaller commission restrictions, whereas tied agents will be subject to comparatively larger ones.
Product Mix Could Decide the Impact
The effect can vary from one insurer to another due to the variation in the business model of the companies. Systematix has pointed out that the existing cost structure depends upon the mix of products such as term insurance, savings insurance, ULIP insurance, and annuity insurance, as well as single premium and regular premium business.
SBI Life Could See a Relatively Lower Impact
SBI Life is seen as the primary outlier by Systematix in terms of expense ratio, which is close to the expense ratio cap that has been proposed. It is believed that the proposed rules would need to be reviewed further because of the nature of the proposed cap.
Also Read: Paras Defence receives ₹26.59 Cr order from DRDO for Hyperspectral Mission
Conclusion
The proposed reforms by IRDAI can have an impact on the structure of costs and distribution for the life insurance sector. Strict controls on expenses and commissions may force insurers to focus on cost-effectiveness as well as revisit their distribution strategies. Nonetheless, the effects would not be the same for all companies depending on their products and premiums. Thus, it would be important to monitor how the insurers cope with the new system.
Systematix target price
